13+ Chia Seed Pudding Recipes with Yogurt (Creamy Flavor Variations)

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our privacy policy.

Looking for chia seed pudding recipes with yogurt and plenty of flavor options? You’re in the right place.

This list brings together creamy chia pudding variations made with milk and yogurt, including chocolate, strawberry, vanilla, and fruit-based options. Each recipe starts from the same simple chia base and changes the flavor with easy ingredients you probably already have.

If you want chia pudding that’s thicker, creamier, and more exciting than the classic version, these flavor ideas make it easy to keep breakfast interesting.

And if you already have a favorite chia pudding recipe, there’s a short guide at the end on how to add yogurt to it without messing up the texture or flavor.

Chia Pudding with Yogurt Flavors

All of the flavors below are made with a creamy milk-and-yogurt chia pudding base. Click a flavor to jump to it, or scroll for inspiration.

• Plain
• Chocolate
• Chocolate banana
• Peanut butter jelly
• Peanut butter banana
• Apple cinnamon
• Apple cranberry
• Pear
• Cranberry
• Blueberry
• Strawberry
• Lemon
• Mango
• Coconut

Greek Yogurt Chia Pudding

The simplest, creamiest option made with milk, Greek yogurt, chia seeds, and a touch of sweetener. A neutral base that pairs well with almost any topping.

Chocolate Chia Pudding

A rich, no-fuss chocolate chia pudding made by stirring cocoa powder into the yogurt-milk base. Deep chocolate flavor with minimal effort.

Chocolate Banana Chia Pudding

Chocolate and banana make this version naturally sweet and extra creamy. A slightly more indulgent option that still works well for breakfast.

PB Jelly Chia Pudding

Peanut butter and jelly chia pudding is pure nostalgia in a jar. Comforting and satisfying, with just enough peanut butter for flavor without feeling heavy.

PB Banana Chia Pudding

A cozy, hearty chia pudding that combines peanut butter with fresh banana sweetness. Perfect for slower mornings or when you want something more filling.

Apple Cinnamon

Warm spices and tender apples make this chia pudding especially comforting. The apple topping adds natural sweetness, so the base stays lightly sweetened.

Apple Cranberry Chia Pudding

A festive chia pudding layered with sweet-tart apple and cranberry flavors. Bright, cozy, and perfect for fall mornings or holiday-style meal prep.

Pear Chia Pudding

Silky pear compote with gentle spices and a hint of lemon gives this chia pudding a soft, elegant flavor. Especially comforting in cooler months.

Cranberry Chia Pudding

Simple chia pudding topped with cranberry sauce for a bold, tart contrast. A great winter breakfast or lighter holiday-inspired snack.

Blueberry Chia Pudding

Sweet-tart blueberries give this chia pudding a vibrant purple color and classic berry flavor. Frozen blueberries work perfectly here.

Strawberry Chia Pudding

Fresh, bright, and lightly sweet, this strawberry chia pudding works well with both fresh and frozen berries. A reliable crowd-pleaser.

Lemon Chia Pudding

Light, zesty, and refreshing, lemon chia pudding adds a citrusy twist to the creamy yogurt base. Great if you enjoy dessert-style breakfasts.

Mango Chia Pudding

Smooth mango purée layered over creamy chia pudding creates bold tropical flavor and beautiful contrast. One of the most visually striking options.

Coconut Chia Pudding

Coconut milk (the carton variety) and shredded coconut bring tropical flavor without heaviness. Try pairing it with pineapple for an easy piña colada-inspired pudding.

How to Add Yogurt to Any Chia Pudding Recipe

If you already have a favorite chia seed pudding recipe but want to make it creamier or higher in protein, adding yogurt (especially Greek yogurt) is an easy upgrade.

Most chia pudding recipes use about ⅔ cup milk per serving. To add yogurt without breaking the texture, start with one of these options:

Option 1: Replace Half the Milk with Greek Yogurt

• Replace ⅓ cup milk with ⅓ cup Greek yogurt
• Adds roughly 7–8 g of protein
• For best texture, reduce the chia seeds by ½ tablespoon so the pudding doesn’t get too thick

Flavor note: Yogurt works especially well with fruity and creamy flavors (vanilla, mango, chocolate), less so with stronger earthier flavors (like pumpkin). Also, adding yogurt adds a bit of tang, which you may need to balance with a touch more sweetener.

Option 2: Small Boost, No Recipe Changes

• Stir in 1 tablespoon of Greek yogurt
• Adds a subtle creaminess and ~1,5 g of protein
• No need to change the milk or chia seed amounts

This is a great option if you don’t want to rebalance the recipe at all.

Tip: Greek yogurt works best for thick, creamy chia pudding. If you’re using regular yogurt, expect a slightly looser texture and adjust chia seeds if needed.

Sharing is caring!